Cash can be useful without becoming a market-timing tool

There is also an important distinction between holding cash because you have a risk-management reason and holding cash because you believe you can predict the bottom.

Cash can serve several legitimate purposes. It can provide liquidity. It can reduce portfolio risk. It can support spending needs. It can allow an investor to take advantage of exceptional opportunities. It can provide psychological comfort that reduces the probability of making a forced sale.

But cash becomes much more difficult when its entire purpose is:

“I am waiting for the stock market crash.”

Because now the investor has made two forecasts. First, that a crash will occur. Second, that the crash will occur before the opportunity cost of sitting in cash becomes too high. If the market continues rising for several years, the cost of waiting can become substantial. There is no free option. Every portfolio decision has an opportunity cost.

The role of humility in investing

This is ultimately an issue of intellectual humility. I know there are things I can analyse and things I cannot know.

I can study a company's annual report, examine its historical financial statements, analyse its competitive position, build valuation ranges, study management's capital allocation. I can compare the current market price with my estimate of intrinsic value and decide whether my assumptions are conservative enough. I can determine how much capital I am willing to put at risk and monitor whether the original investment thesis remains intact.

But I cannot know with certainty when the next market crash will begin and cannot know with certainty when it will end. I cannot know the exact lowest price that every stock in my portfolio will reach. And I cannot know in advance whether the next market recovery will begin tomorrow or six months from now.

Recognising these limits is not weakness. It is part of rational decision-making.

An investor does not become more sophisticated by pretending to know things that cannot reliably be known. Sophistication often means understanding where your knowledge ends.

My responsibility is to manage capital, not to perform magic

As my family's investment manager, I have a responsibility to protect and compound family capital. That responsibility requires me to take risk seriously. It also requires me to distinguish between productive risk and unnecessary risk.

Trying to predict every major market turning point introduces a form of risk that I do not believe is necessary. The risk is not simply that the forecast could be wrong. The bigger risk is that the forecast could be right, but the implementation could still be wrong.

There are many ways for a seemingly intelligent strategy to fail. This is why I prefer a process where fewer things have to go right.

The fewer predictions required, the better

This may be one of the deepest principles behind my investment philosophy. A very good investment process should minimise the number of things you need to predict correctly.

If your strategy requires you to correctly forecast interest rates, inflation, GDP growth, recessions, geopolitical events, market sentiment, the beginning of a crash, the bottom of a crash, the recovery, and the exact behaviour of individual stocks, then you are building a system that depends on a very large number of uncertain forecasts.

The probability of getting every major decision right becomes increasingly low. A business-focused investment process reduces the number of predictions required. I make conservative assumptions and estimate future earnings. But I can make those assumptions over a longer time horizon and focus on the economics of businesses rather than attempting to predict every short-term movement in the market.

This is one reason I believe long-term investing is fundamentally a discipline of reducing unnecessary decisions.

The best time to prepare for a crash is before it happens

The irony is that preparing for a crash doesn't require predicting it. You can prepare by:

  1. Owning businesses with strong economics
  2. Avoiding excessive leverage
  3. Understanding the balance sheets of the companies you own
  4. Maintaining sufficient liquidity
  5. Knowing your valuation ranges before the market becomes emotional
  6. Deciding in advance what would make you buy more
  7. Deciding what would invalidate your investment thesis
  8. Understanding which risks could permanently impair intrinsic value

Then, when the market declines sharply, you are not starting your analysis from zero. You already know what you own. You already know what you think it is worth. You already know which companies deserve additional capital if prices become sufficiently attractive. That is a much more useful form of preparation than trying to predict the exact date of the next crash.

Long-term investing requires the ability to do nothing

There is another uncomfortable truth about investing. Sometimes the correct decision is to do nothing. For an active person, this can feel unsatisfying. There is always another headline. Another forecast, recession warning, valuation chart, geopolitical crisis, analyst predicting a market crash, stock market expert predicting a bull market. The investor can therefore feel compelled to act.

But action is not the same thing as progress. Sometimes the highest-value decision is simply to continue owning a great business whose intrinsic value is rising. The absence of a transaction does not mean the absence of investment management. Monitoring a portfolio, reviewing business performance, updating valuations, and deciding that no action is required can itself be disciplined capital allocation.

What I ultimately tell my mother

When my mother asks whether we should sell everything before the next crash, my answer is therefore quite simple.

If I genuinely believe the long-term value of the businesses we own has materially deteriorated, I will consider selling a large portion of the stock of these businesses in our investment portfolio that are most badly affected. If the stock of a business becomes egregiously overvalued relative to a reasonable estimate of intrinsic value, I will consider reducing or exiting the position. If our family's liquidity requirements change, I will adjust the portfolio. If the risk of permanent capital loss has materially increased, I should act.

But selling simply because someone predicts that the overall market might crash creates a different problem. I would have to know when to sell. Then I would have to know when to buy. Then I would have to know which individual stocks to buy. Then I would have to know how much to buy. And I would have to do all of this while the information needed to make those decisions is still incomplete and highly uncertain. That is an extremely demanding forecasting exercise. I would rather allocate capital based on things I can understand.

The bottom is only visible in the rear-view mirror

The most important lesson is therefore simple. The exact bottom of a market crash is visible only after the market has already passed it. The same is true of the exact top. In real time, we are always operating with incomplete information. The investor who accepts this reality can build a process around it.

Not required

You do not need to predict every crash. You do not need to buy at the exact bottom. You do not need to know what the market will do next quarter or year. You do not need to win every short-term forecasting contest.

Required

You need to survive the crashes. You need to buy at prices that offer attractive long-term expected returns. You need to understand what the businesses you own can reasonably earn over many years. You need to compound capital over a long period without suffering permanent impairment.

This is why I continue to believe that the core of long-term investing is fundamentally different from market timing. Market timing asks:

“Where will the market go next?”

Fundamental investing asks:

“What am I buying, what is it worth, and what return can I reasonably expect from owning it at today's price?”

The first question may produce an interesting forecast. The second can produce an investment decision. That distinction matters.

Because markets will always give us another crash. Another recession, geopolitical crisis, tariff shock, valuation scare, expert with a confident prediction. We cannot control any of these things. What we can control is the quality of our investment process. We can control what we buy, the price we are willing to pay, our position sizes, our use of leverage, how much research we do, and whether we understand the businesses we own. And, perhaps most importantly, we can control whether we allow fear and excitement to turn a long-term investment strategy into a series of short-term guesses.

For me, that is the real purpose of long-term investing.

I am not trying to predict every storm. I am trying to own businesses that can survive the storm, compound through it, and become more valuable over time. And when the market gives me the opportunity to buy those businesses at unusually attractive prices, I want to have the knowledge, liquidity, and conviction to act.

That is a much more realistic objective than trying to sell everything at the top and buy everything back at the bottom.

The top and bottom are obvious only in hindsight. The investment opportunity exists in the uncertainty between them.

Intellectual humility Cash and liquidity Investment process Behavioural investing Long-term investing